Does the Bible Contradict Itself?
Ah, those postmodernists. They never let up. It seems James Dee, a retired professor of classics from the University of Texas has pontificated from his writer’s desk about the Bible again. He says it’s obviously not inspired by God, that it’s obvious Moses didn’t write the first five books, and it is obvious Matthew contradicts John.
Let me comment just briefly on the good professor’s objections. First, the books of Moses never make the claim that Moses wrote every word in them. In fact, scripture indicates that Moses did not write all the material in the Pentateuch. Numbers 12:3 reads, “Now the man Moses was very humble, more so than anyone else on the face of the earth.” It is doubtful that Moses would have written these words about himself. Far more likely it is that Joshua or some other scribe, inspired by the Spirit, penned these comments.
Secondly, Dee says Matthew contradicts John. Think about this: why are there four gospel accounts? It seemed like one would have sufficed. Maybe it’s because Matthew, Mark, Luke and John each wrote in a different time to a different audience and wanted to help their audience comprehend the story from their own cultural backgrounds. Make sense, perhaps? That’s why Matthew, the very Jewish scribe, leads his genealogy back to Abraham, while Luke, the Gentile, leads his back to Adam. Matthew speaks of the “Kingdom of heaven,” while Mark in parallel readings mentions the “kingdom of God.” Jewish people tried not to even say the name “God” in order to avoid using the Lord’s name in vain, while to Gentiles, “Heaven” was the abode of the gods. Hence, Mark identifies the kingdom of the one true God, rather than “heaven” where his Greek audience would have been confused with the idea of many gods living there.
Understanding this, it is possible that John, to suit his audience arranges materials in a way that is not always chronological. He places the cleansing of the temple at the start of Jesus’ ministry, instead of at the end, as do Matthew, Mark and Luke, in order to make the resurrection of Lazarus the catalyst of our Lord’s crucifixion, rather than the interruption of the livestock market and money-changing trade. It’s just an idea. It makes good sense. And, John did indicate at the end of his book that Jesus did and said so many things that a vast library couldn’t have recorded them all –John 21:25.
A neat fact about the Bible is that, although written by an estimated forty different authors over a period of perhaps 1500 years, it maintains a remarkable unity throughout. There is just one God. He has a law, and He makes demands on us in righteousness. Righteousness and goodness are clearly defined, and individuals, families and societies are much better when they try to keep His standards.And, He has saved the world through faith in His only Son, Jesus Christ.
Your secularism provides absolutely no hope for the future, Prof. Dee. The Bible, on the other hand reminds us that the miracle of life and the vast universe indicate to us there is certainly another existence beyond this one, an existence in which life is fair. And you do understand fairness, Dee, because I’m always hearing people cry, “That’s not fair!” God agrees. He defines what is fair. And in His heaven, things will be fair.
You can trust the Bible. Greater men than James Dee have tried to discredit it. They’ve all failed. Trust in the Lord and His promises.
Let me comment just briefly on the good professor’s objections. First, the books of Moses never make the claim that Moses wrote every word in them. In fact, scripture indicates that Moses did not write all the material in the Pentateuch. Numbers 12:3 reads, “Now the man Moses was very humble, more so than anyone else on the face of the earth.” It is doubtful that Moses would have written these words about himself. Far more likely it is that Joshua or some other scribe, inspired by the Spirit, penned these comments.
Secondly, Dee says Matthew contradicts John. Think about this: why are there four gospel accounts? It seemed like one would have sufficed. Maybe it’s because Matthew, Mark, Luke and John each wrote in a different time to a different audience and wanted to help their audience comprehend the story from their own cultural backgrounds. Make sense, perhaps? That’s why Matthew, the very Jewish scribe, leads his genealogy back to Abraham, while Luke, the Gentile, leads his back to Adam. Matthew speaks of the “Kingdom of heaven,” while Mark in parallel readings mentions the “kingdom of God.” Jewish people tried not to even say the name “God” in order to avoid using the Lord’s name in vain, while to Gentiles, “Heaven” was the abode of the gods. Hence, Mark identifies the kingdom of the one true God, rather than “heaven” where his Greek audience would have been confused with the idea of many gods living there.
Understanding this, it is possible that John, to suit his audience arranges materials in a way that is not always chronological. He places the cleansing of the temple at the start of Jesus’ ministry, instead of at the end, as do Matthew, Mark and Luke, in order to make the resurrection of Lazarus the catalyst of our Lord’s crucifixion, rather than the interruption of the livestock market and money-changing trade. It’s just an idea. It makes good sense. And, John did indicate at the end of his book that Jesus did and said so many things that a vast library couldn’t have recorded them all –John 21:25.
A neat fact about the Bible is that, although written by an estimated forty different authors over a period of perhaps 1500 years, it maintains a remarkable unity throughout. There is just one God. He has a law, and He makes demands on us in righteousness. Righteousness and goodness are clearly defined, and individuals, families and societies are much better when they try to keep His standards.And, He has saved the world through faith in His only Son, Jesus Christ.
Your secularism provides absolutely no hope for the future, Prof. Dee. The Bible, on the other hand reminds us that the miracle of life and the vast universe indicate to us there is certainly another existence beyond this one, an existence in which life is fair. And you do understand fairness, Dee, because I’m always hearing people cry, “That’s not fair!” God agrees. He defines what is fair. And in His heaven, things will be fair.
You can trust the Bible. Greater men than James Dee have tried to discredit it. They’ve all failed. Trust in the Lord and His promises.
